YABRL: Deep Sjeng 1.6 does not quite reach the Ruffians

[Robert Allgeuer]

Geschrieben von: / Posted by: Robert Allgeuer at 09 March 2004 23:12:25:

As the situation appears to be a bit unclear with respect to the new Ruffian versions (which one is strongest, maybe Leiden or some betas are even better than 2.x etc.) I decided to wait and see a bit with respect to Ruffian and to test Deep Sjeng 1.6 instead.
After 719 unique games Deep Sjeng 1.6 comes in as third, some 20 points behind Ruffian 1.0.1. A bit a surprise: it was Pepito 1.59 that scored the highest against Deep Sjeng. On place 4 there is now a four-way tie between Thinker, Ktulu, Smarthink and Crafty 17.14.
The suffix ntb means btw that Deep Sjeng 1.6 (just like Crafty 19.6) is playing without EGTBs. The reason is that the 6 piece tablebase code does not run on my computer for unknown reasons; various advice (installation of .net framework etc.) that I received did not resolve the problem. Anyway, EGTBs would have almost no influence on the playing strength, at most 10 ELO if not 0 points.
Time control is 300+2, for exact conditions, platform and tools please see link below. Pharaon is now the new fixed reference point with a rating of 2509.
I will go on a 11 day holiday now, YABRL will take a break; during my absence (hope there will be no power cut) I will run a book test with Crafty instead.
Robert



    Program                      Elo    +   -   Games   Score   Av.Op.  Draws
 01 Ruffian v2.0.0            : 2679   17  28   820    72.1 %   2514   24.9 %
 02 Ruffian v1.0.1            : 2652   17  25   896    69.8 %   2507   26.5 %
 03 DeepSjeng v1.6ntb         : 2632   20  26   719    66.3 %   2514   24.8 %
 04 Thinker v4.5b             : 2592   21  21   756    60.7 %   2516   32.8 %
 05 SmarThink v0.17a          : 2592   21  22   799    60.6 %   2517   25.4 %
 06 Crafty v17.14DC           : 2592   18  19   979    60.9 %   2515   32.4 %
 07 Ktulu v4.2                : 2592   20  23   795    61.1 %   2513   23.9 %
 08 Crafty v19.06DCntb        : 2584   20  20   841    59.4 %   2518   30.8 %
 09 Aristarch v4.21           : 2583   19  20   997    59.7 %   2515   24.4 %
 10 Aristarch v4.37           : 2575   22  19   779    58.5 %   2516   36.8 %
 11 Crafty-MPC v18.15DC       : 2572   20  20   904    58.4 %   2513   27.4 %
 12 Delfi v4.3                : 2568   20  20   920    57.8 %   2514   24.5 %
 13 El Chinito v3.25          : 2567   22  21   760    57.8 %   2513   27.9 %
 14 Delfi v4.2                : 2565   25  25   580    58.1 %   2508   27.2 %
 15 SmarThink v0.16b++        : 2562   21  21   836    58.0 %   2507   24.3 %
 16 Crafty v18.15DC           : 2560   22  22   741    59.0 %   2497   29.0 %
 17 Little Goliath 2000 v3.9  : 2559   20  18  1000    56.3 %   2515   26.4 %
 18 Pepito v1.59 profile      : 2559   20  19  1000    56.2 %   2515   25.6 %
 19 SoS 3                     : 2557   20  19   999    55.9 %   2515   22.5 %
 20 Yace Paderborn            : 2554   20  19   980    55.9 %   2513   26.3 %
 21 Aristarch v4.4            : 2551   36  34   319    54.1 %   2522   20.4 %
 22 SoS 4                     : 2549   23  21   779    55.0 %   2514   24.3 %
 23 Yace v0.99.56             : 2545   33  29   380    54.3 %   2515   26.6 %
 24 Green Light Chess v3.00   : 2542   21  18  1000    53.8 %   2516   25.3 %
 25 Little Goliath 2000 v3.5  : 2540   31  25   440    53.6 %   2515   30.9 %
 26 Anmon v5.30               : 2522   25  19   760    51.2 %   2514   27.0 %
 27 Amyan v1.59               : 2517   23  18   892    50.3 %   2514   25.8 %
 28 Pharaon v2.62             : 2509   18  22   999    48.9 %   2516   23.9 %
 29 Crafty v19.01DC           : 2503   24  19   815    50.4 %   2500   25.5 %
 30 LambChop v10.99           : 2500   18  21   998    47.7 %   2516   22.8 %
 31 Gromit v3.8.2             : 2495   18  21   977    47.0 %   2516   23.1 %
 32 Ktulu v3.9                : 2495   19  24   779    48.6 %   2505   26.1 %
 33 SlowChess v2.89b          : 2490   19  22   878    46.2 %   2516   23.9 %
 34 KnightDreamer v3.2        : 2487   19  22   900    46.0 %   2515   25.1 %
 35 Anmon v5.22               : 2487   19  22   899    46.4 %   2512   26.7 %
 36 Amy v0.8.3                : 2482   20  20   989    45.1 %   2516   19.1 %
 37 Tao v5.4                  : 2482   19  20   999    45.0 %   2517   20.9 %
 38 Comet B44-2               : 2481   19  21   920    44.9 %   2516   27.3 %
 39 SoS v11-99                : 2480   33  34   359    46.0 %   2508   17.3 %
 40 Dragon v4.4.3             : 2471   20  21   866    43.9 %   2513   25.5 %
 41 Comet B62-3               : 2461   20  20   900    42.2 %   2515   25.8 %
 42 Francesca M.0.0.9         : 2446   20  18   999    39.8 %   2518   25.4 %
 43 PostModernist v1.007      : 2446   21  19   920    39.9 %   2517   25.3 %
 44 Comet B60                 : 2438   22  21   780    41.2 %   2500   25.6 %
 45 Leila v0.53h              : 2430   23  19   918    37.7 %   2517   21.6 %
 46 Tcb v0045                 : 2427   22  19   919    37.3 %   2517   25.0 %
 47 Resp v0.19                : 2408   23  18   900    34.9 %   2516   23.9 %
 48 Nejmet v3.07              : 2392   25  18   876    33.2 %   2514   22.3 %
 49 SlowChess v2.78           : 2382   27  19   790    33.5 %   2501   19.6 %
 50 Exchess v4.03             : 2332   30  16   899    25.6 %   2518   22.0 %
 51 Beowulf v2.2              : 2311   33  15   980    23.1 %   2520   18.1 %

Games        :  21465 (finished)
White Wins   :   8725 (40.6 %)
Black Wins   :   7336 (34.2 %)
Draws        :   5404 (25.2 %)
Unfinished   :      0
White Perf.  : 53.2 %
Black Perf.  : 46.8 %

(3) DeepSjeng v1.6ntb         : 719 (+388,=178,-153), 66.3 %
Ruffian v2.0.0                :  20 (+  6,=  7,-  7), 47.5 %
SmarThink v0.17a              :  20 (+ 12,=  4,-  4), 70.0 %
Ktulu v4.2                    :  20 (+  9,=  7,-  4), 62.5 %
Crafty v17.14DC               :  19 (+  8,=  8,-  3), 63.2 %
Thinker v4.5b                 :  20 (+  8,=  6,-  6), 55.0 %
Crafty v19.06DCntb            :  20 (+  8,=  9,-  3), 62.5 %
Aristarch v4.21               :  20 (+ 11,=  3,-  6), 62.5 %
Aristarch v4.37               :  20 (+  7,=  9,-  4), 57.5 %
Crafty-MPC v18.15DC           :  20 (+  8,=  3,-  9), 47.5 %
Delfi v4.3                    :  20 (+ 10,=  7,-  3), 67.5 %
El Chinito v3.25              :  20 (+  9,=  7,-  4), 62.5 %
Little Goliath 2000 v3.9      :  20 (+ 11,=  6,-  3), 70.0 %
SoS 3                         :  20 (+  9,=  3,-  8), 52.5 %
SoS 4                         :  20 (+ 11,=  3,-  6), 62.5 %
Pepito v1.59 profile          :  20 (+  4,=  7,-  9), 37.5 %
Yace v0.99.56                 :  20 (+  6,=  9,-  5), 52.5 %
Green Light Chess v3.00       :  20 (+  7,=  6,-  7), 50.0 %
Anmon v5.30                   :  20 (+ 10,=  5,-  5), 62.5 %
Amyan v1.59                   :  20 (+ 15,=  1,-  4), 77.5 %
Pharaon v2.62                 :  20 (+ 15,=  4,-  1), 85.0 %
LambChop v10.99               :  20 (+ 10,=  5,-  5), 62.5 %
Gromit v3.8.2                 :  20 (+ 13,=  2,-  5), 70.0 %
SlowChess v2.89b              :  20 (+ 14,=  3,-  3), 77.5 %
KnightDreamer v3.2            :  20 (+ 11,=  5,-  4), 67.5 %
Amy v0.8.3                    :  20 (+ 15,=  0,-  5), 75.0 %
Tao v5.4                      :  20 (+ 11,=  5,-  4), 67.5 %
Comet B44-2                   :  20 (+ 12,=  6,-  2), 75.0 %
Dragon v4.4.3                 :  20 (+  8,=  8,-  4), 60.0 %
Comet B62-3                   :  20 (+ 12,=  4,-  4), 70.0 %
Francesca M.0.0.9             :  20 (+ 15,=  2,-  3), 80.0 %
PostModernist v1.007          :  20 (+ 10,=  4,-  6), 60.0 %
Leila v0.53h                  :  20 (+ 12,=  6,-  2), 75.0 %
Tcb v0045                     :  20 (+ 13,=  5,-  2), 77.5 %
Resp v0.19                    :  20 (+ 13,=  6,-  1), 80.0 %
Exchess v4.03                 :  20 (+ 19,=  0,-  1), 95.0 %
Beowulf v2.2                  :  20 (+ 16,=  3,-  1), 87.5 %





YABRL (Yet Another Blitz Rating List)